I took Preteen to see the Iowa City Community Theatre production of To Kill a Mockingbird on Saturday night. (Teen had a better offer…though I’m not sure how going to a LAN party and hooking a bunch of computers together really qualifies as “better” than going to see live theatre…) Preteen and I had a great time! A friend of mine had a small part…her daughter had the lead. Plus one of Preteen’s past directors also had a part…and we knew all three of the kids who were in it because they’ve been in Young Footliter’s productions with Preteen. I was planning on going to see this production anyway, but it’s even more fun when you know some of the people who are in the show!

I was happy that Preteen actually liked the story, too…that it wasn’t just about going to see people he knew. Now I would’ve thought he would’ve liked the story all along. But when auditions were announced a couple months ago, he was all set to try out (he thought it would be fun to do a show with adults, rather than just kids)…until I told him what the story was about. I have no idea why or how I turned him off, but somehow I did. (Though it certainly made my life easier not having to drive him to rehearsals the last two months….) And of course, during the intermission, he said he wished he had tried out after all. Oh well.

On the way home we had a nice discussion about what makes a book, movie or TV show a “classic.” Well, we had a “nice discussion” until I told him that while Stargate SG-1 is a great show, I’m not sure it’s a “classic.” Then he got mad at me.

We continued our conversation when we got home. And Teen was home by then, so he put in his two cents, too (he did agree with me on Stargate SG-1, BTW). Teen and I have had numerous conversations about what makes something a classic, too. He thinks personal opinion has a lot to do with it. But I’m not so sure about that…I think there are books/movies/TV shows that almost everyone would agree are classics. To Kill a Mockingbird is one example.

Much of these conversations I’ve had with Teen have centered around Catcher in the Rye. He thinks Catcher in the Rye is way over-rated. I, on the other hand, LOVE that book! I personally think Lord of the Rings is over-rated, but that doesn’t mean it’s not a “classic.”

I think a classic:

1) stands the test of time
2) breaks new ground
3) is something that, for whatever reason, touches a wide range of people

So then Teen brought up Miracle on 34th Street (the original black and white version! I’m sorry, but remaking Miracle on 34th Street, setting it in modern times, doing it in color…all of that is just plain WRONG!). This is one of my favorite movies. I think it’s a classic. It’s certainly stood the test of time…it touches a wide variety of people…but did it break new ground? Hmm…I’m not sure.

Okay, maybe personal opinion DOES factor in…


What is a “classic?”

4 thoughts on “What is a “classic?”

  • April 30, 2007 at 7:36 pm
    Permalink

    So…if SG-1 isn’t a classic, would the original Star Trek, according to your three points? šŸ™‚ Maybe that would make preteen happy???

    What a wide variety of interests your family has!

    Reply
    • April 30, 2007 at 7:57 pm
      Permalink

      Ha! Star Trek came up Saturday night, too. I think Star Trek is a classic…certainly within the science fiction genre (and there’s another whole issue to consider? Are some books/movies/TV shows classics with a genre, but not classics as a whole?).

      And who knows? Maybe SG-1 WILL turn out to be a classic, too? (Believe me, if it does, Preteen will remind me of this conversation when it does!)

      And FWIW, *I* like SG-1 better than Star Trek!

      Do you watch SG-1, too?

      Reply
      • April 30, 2007 at 8:00 pm
        Permalink

        I rarely watch TV these days, but SG-1 was one that DH and I watched together–and I liked it. I never liked any sci-fi or fantasy before I met him. Before we had kids, Friday night was Star Trek TNG night. We’d drink a bottle of wine and watch The Next Generation. I didn’t like it at first, but grew to enjoy that one too.

        Reply
        • April 30, 2007 at 8:09 pm
          Permalink

          Our whole family watched SG-1. I never liked SF or fantasy before I met my husband, either. (I did play Star Trek during recess when I was in elementary school, but I never really liked the show/franchise until my family started watching Deep Space 9)

          My husband got our kids into SF/fantasy…and eventually it grew on me, too.

          Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *